Âé¶¹¹ú²ú

Skip to main content
Advertising

NFL trade grades: Which 2026 offseason moves earned the best marks? The worst?

Kevin Patra grades the most significant NFL trades of the 2026 offseason.

RUNNING BACK

David Montgomery trade

Grade
C+
Houston Texans

Texans receive:

Grade
A-
Detroit Lions

Lions receive:

  • IOL Juice Scruggs
  • 2026 4th-round pick
  • 2027 7th-round pick


Montgomery immediately vaults to the top of Houston's backfield in an offense that desperately needs more production on the ground after losing Joe Mixon to a mysterious foot injury. Montgomery profiles as the type of bruising back that DeMeco Ryans wants to deploy. His gritty running ability was something the Texans sorely missed last season, particularly in short-yardage and goal-line situations. He pairs well with shifty pass-catching back Woody Marks and should see the bulk of the early-down carries.


The fact that Houston GM Nick Caserio pulled the trigger on the trade directly following the NFL Scouting Combine could be an indicator that he sensed pricey figures emerging for the top backs hitting free agency and had no plans to get into those bidding wars.


I believe Montgomery has juice left, and his contract isn’t exorbitant, costing roughly $6 million this season and $9 million (non-guaranteed) in 2027 -- unless the Texans re-do the deal, as they did two years ago when they acquired Mixon.


Houston gets knocked here because the cost -- two picks, including a valuable fourth-rounder, and a player -- isn't exactly cheap for a soon-to-be 29-year-old early-down back. That price suggests there was a market for Montgomery ahead of free agency.


The offensive line was the bigger culprit for Houston's rushing struggles. Whether Caserio is able to round out the offseason by bolstering that unit will significantly influence the backfield’s improvement with Montgomery in 2026.


Lions GM Brad Holmes did excellent work to get a respectable haul for a running back he seemed destined to part ways with this offseason. The fourth-round selection is key for a club that needs to fill out its depth after a disappointing 2025. Scruggs has struggled, but he brings depth to an interior O-line that entered this offseason needing a facelift. The former second-rounder is worth a flier to see if a change of scenery is beneficial. At worst, he was a toss-in for a backup running back.


Detroit now finds itself with a bit more cash to eventually pay Jahmyr Gibbs in a deal that should be at (or near) the top of the RB market. Given Holmes’ propensity to do deals early, that extension could come this offseason. However, the Lions now need a new power element to pair with their speed demon. They should look for a cheap veteran or add a back in the middle rounds of the draft -- or both.  

WIDE RECEIVER

DJ Moore trade

Grade
B-
Buffalo Bills

Bills receive:

  • WR DJ Moore
  • 2026 5th-round pick
Grade
A-
Chicago Bears

Bears receive:

  • 2026 2nd-round pick


The Bills couldn't sit by and waste another season of Josh Allen's prime by continuing to trot out a subpar wide receiver crew. They couldn't bank on Keon Coleman magically putting it all together in Year 3. They couldn't count on Khalil Shakir breaking 75 tackles every time he touches the ball in order for the offense to move. Buffalo had to take swings at upgrading an ineffective (ninth-fewest yards in the league last year), injury-riddled receiver room -- a unit that had become a huge thorn in general manager Brandon Beane's side.


From that perspective, you can certainly see why the Bills made the move. With cap issues, they were unlikely to be big players for the top free agents, and at Pick No. 26, they couldn't bank on a game-breaker falling in a questionable draft. Moore brings experience in Joe Brady's system, having generated 1,000-plus yards in each of the two seasons when the new Bills coach was the OC in Carolina. He fits well as a boundary target next to Shakir, stretching the field for Allen. Moore is a proven commodity who can get open in an offense that struggled mightily in that area this past season, particularly on third downs. He immediately makes Allen's life easier.


The concern, however, is that Moore's age has begun to show. In 2024, he averaged a career-worst 9.9 yards per catch, and last year, he posted career lows in receptions (50) and receiving yards (682). Were the struggles in Ben Johnson's offense a byproduct of the system, younger receivers garnering more targets and an attack with more mouths to feed? Or is the cliff approaching? The Bills are banking heavily on the soon-to-be 29-year-old returning to form under Brady.


The cost wasn't exactly cheap. Buffalo will take on the rest of Moore's contract, including a $24.5 million cap charge in 2026, . The Bills can reduce that figure in the short term by restructuring the deal once the trade goes through, but they will also take on $15.5 million in guaranteed money in 2027. For a club already up against it money-wise, things get no easier.


The pick swap will drop Buffalo about a hundred draft slots, from Round 2 to Round 5. In a draft that's in the second and third rounds, the Bills are essentially moving from grabbing a potential starter on a cost-controlled contract to rolling the dice on a possible rotational player. On a team that needs low-cost contributors, that's significant.


The Bears did well to obtain a premium pick, giving Ryan Poles four selection in the top 100 of the 2026 NFL Draft to either stock the roster or use in another trade.


Moore made some spectacular catches last season in Chicago's magical run, but he had been bypassed by Rome Odunze as WR1 and was poised to lose even more targets to Luther Burden III, who fills the slot role better than the veteran. Add in tight end Colston Loveland's burgeoning skills, and Moore became superfluous in Johnson's offense. Given Moore's contract, Chicago always appeared poised to move on this offseason.


Shedding the cap space while jumping into a premium spot in the draft was an ideal move for Poles, who doesn't seem like he's done making splash plays. The trade will free up $16.5 million on the cap for the Bears to chase a potential pass rusher or solidify the center position after Pro Bowler Drew Dalman's abrupt retirement.


Given Moore's age, recent production and cost, this is an excellent return for the Bears, allowing them to be more flexible this offseason.

OFFENSIVE LINE

Tytus Howard trade

Browns receive:

  • OL Tytus Howard
Grade
B-
Houston Texans

Texans receive:

  • 2026 5th-round pick


To say Cleveland had a glaring need for offensive linemen entering the offseason would be an understatement. With seven blockers hitting free agency, GM Andrew Berry was in for a complete overhaul. Howard’s versatility is extremely useful for the Browns, who were facing significant needs on the interior and at right tackle. They can head to the market without being pigeonholed into one spot or another; rather, they can chase all positions and let the starters sort themselves out.


Howard's NFL tenure has been somewhat of a roller-coaster ride. He showed promise as a pass protector, particularly earlier in his career, but has struggled in the run game -- as did most of Houston’s offensive line in 2025. If he had played more consistently, the Texans wouldn’t have moved on. For a Browns team with double-digit selections, ceding a fifth-round pick was a middling cost. However, Cleveland doubled down, giving Howard a three-year, $63 million deal. That’s sinking a lot into an average starter.


Considering the Browns’ need, at least they head into free agency with one answer along a lonely O-line, even given the cost.


For a Houston team still trying to figure out its offensive line, GM Nick Caserio is certainly willing to shuffle the deck. Howard, for all his faults, was one of the Texans' better blockers last season. Perhaps that’s not saying much, but giving that depth away for a Day 3 pick raises an eyebrow. While the Texans on a one-year deal, they still have major questions up front, with RG Ed Ingram set to hit the open market following a solid debut season in Houston.


An additional benefit for Houston is that the move saves some cash in the immediate future, and the Texans need to lock down their true playmakers, including edge rusher Will Anderson Jr.

DEFENSIVE LINE

Jermaine Johnson II-T'Vondre Sweat trade

Grade
A-
New York Jets

Jets receive:

Grade
C+
Tennessee Titans

Titans receive:

  • DE Jermaine Johnson II


The Jets might still be stuck on the tarmac as an organization, but at least GM Darren Mougey has proven he can get value in the trade market. Following up on last year’s good trade-deadline deals, which brought New York a slew of precious draft assets, Mougey moved on from an edge rusher in the final year of his contract who wasn’t a great fit for the defense Aaron Glenn wants to employ in 2026, receiving a player with upside in return.


Plugging in Sweat alongside Harrison Phillips and Jowon Briggs immediately improves the Jets' porous run defense. The beefy 6-foot-4, 366-pounder is a load in the middle. He can eat up linemen, and when he's at his best, he swallows running backs whole. Sweat might not be a penetrator (he's totaled three sacks in two years), but the former second-rounder's immense size allows him to squeeze the pocket and free up lanes for blitzing linebackers.


There had been questions about Sweat's fit in new Titans coach Robert Saleh's system. If motivated and on point, he’s a low-cost player who could help transform the middle of the Jets' defense. Johnson's $13.4 million contract this offseason also frees up more cap space for Mougey to plug the numerous holes on the roster.


The Titans needed edge help, and Johnson’s previous production under Saleh is a plus. The former first-round pick enjoyed his best pro season on Saleh's 2023 Jets, generating 7.5 sacks and earning a Pro Bowl nod. If Tennessee were ensured Johnson would build on that production, it’d be a highly graded trade. However, the edge rusher hasn’t looked the same since a 2024 Achilles injury and had just three sacks last season. Not counting his injury-derailed '24 campaign, Johnson owns just a 10.7% QB pressure rate, per Next Gen Stats.


Sweat might not have matched the smaller, sleeker profile Saleh prefers from his interior D-linemen, but trading the DT creates a hole next to first-team All-Pro stud Jeffery Simmons. I suspect the Titans will target an option in free agency (John Franklin-Myers?). While Tennessee has extensive cap space to fill this offseason, taking on the final year of Johnson’s rookie deal is nothing to sneeze at, especially considering the meager overall production. The Titans are taking a swing that Johnson will rejuvenate his play under Saleh in a contract season.

CORNERBACK

Trent McDuffie trade

Rams receive:

Chiefs receive:

  • 2026 1st-round pick (No. 29 overall)
  • 2026 5th-round pick
  • 2026 6th-round pick
  • 2027 3rd-round pick


Let’s be clear off the bat: I love Trent McDuffie as a player. He’s physical, quick, highly intelligent and offers flexibility. He’s one of the few corners who can thrive anywhere on the field. The 25-year-old boasts toughness against the run and is excellent when sent on blitzes. Since 2022, McDuffie is the only cornerback in the NFL with 25-plus passes defensed, 15-plus QB hits and 10-plus tackles for loss, per NFL Research.


The Rams are getting an absolute stud. After last year’s postseason struggles in the secondary, Los Angeles needed a bona fide cover corner. McDuffie fits the bill, and his versatility doesn’t rule out adding additional corners in free agency and the draft.


The only knock here is the cost. Yes, L.A. still has the No. 13 overall pick. That makes it easier to swallow giving up a first-rounder, but it doesn’t change the overall calculus. Four picks for one player is obviously a noteworthy price. Couple that with NFL Network Insider Ian Rapoport's that Los Angeles is expected to give McDuffie a new contract that will make him the league's highest-paid corner, and it’s a lot of assets used in one move.


Not that the Rams care about an offseason grade. They’ve gone down this path before. The blockbuster deal for versatile cover man Jalen Ramsey worked out pretty well, and this time around, they didn’t have to give up two first-rounders. With Matthew Stafford hitting his age-38 season, L.A. is in win-now mode and seemingly getting back to its "F--- them picks" standard.


Shipping out McDuffie stings the Chiefs. But, like with the Rams, this is their modus operandi. General manager Brett Veach is allergic to paying corners big money. He traded away Marcus Peters and L'Jarius Sneed. Those decisions didn’t bite Kansas City, so it’s understandable that the team would continue making similar moves. If Veach had zero intentions of paying McDuffie, moving on now makes logical sense. It hurts in the short term, but it’s a long-term play.


The Chiefs entered the offseason cap-strapped and still have several free agents, like S Bryan Cook and CB Jaylen Watson, who could price themselves out of Kansas City. This team is facing the sorts of difficult decisions that come with having a top-heavy roster. Veach is counting on his ability to find answers in the draft -- and on defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo's ability to develop answers. It’s been a proven method so far.


Getting four picks, including a late first-rounder, is solid, if unspectacular. That 2027 third-rounder could prove to be sneaky-great value if next year’s draft is as deep as currently projected. The Chiefs need to replenish their depth with cost-controlled talent. Trading McDuffie helps that play. Of course, now they’re pressed to find the next Trent McDuffie.

Related Content